We Baked Seven Sugar Cookies and Got One

Seven sugar cookies baked together into one sheet on parchment paper

This whole thing was my daughter’s idea. She wanted to make sugar cookies, so in the kitchen we went. We started with a Betty Crocker sugar cookie mix. My wife’s allergic to eggs, so we used egg replacer in it.

We set out to make a batch and ended up with one big cookie instead, but we’ll get to that.

The mix came out a bit dry, on account of the replacer. That’s where I come in, because I took charge of the milk. I added some. Then I added a little more. Somewhere in there I added too much, and that one’s all me. She was following along right; I was pouring by feel. By then it was all mixed and we weren’t starting over.

She did the real work in that kitchen. I mostly supervised and handled the milk, which is pretty much how we got here.

So we rolled it out, cut out our little fellas, and set them on the pan with room to spare. Or so we thought. The oven had other plans. Every one of them spread out until they ran into the next one, and they came out of there baked together in one sheet.

The good news is they taste great. They’re just one hot mess.

The second pan did a little better. Most of them stayed their own cookie that time, candy canes and all. But our gingerbread men spread out and turned into marshmallow figures.

The second pan of sugar cookies: candy canes and snowflakes that held up, and gingerbread men spread out like marshmallow figures

Betty Crocker Sugar Cookie Mix, 17.5 oz

The pouch mix: add butter and an egg, or egg replacer like we did, and it makes about three dozen cookies.

This is the mix we baked with. Even with too much milk and a whole pan baked into one sheet, every cookie came out fresh, soft, and delicious. Just ugly.

See it on Amazon

And here’s the thing about the whole batch: every cookie came out fresh, soft, and delicious, just right. Just ugly.

So if you come by our house and see one giant cookie with seven fellas in it, or a gingerbread man that looks like a marshmallow, don’t judge it by the look. Break off an arm and call it a cookie, we reckon. Kitchen lessons are still lessons, and this one was tasty.

See y’all later,
John